How to think about insurance
Buy for devastating losses; pay out of pocket for survivable annoyances.
By Leo HongReviewed 3 min read
Insurance is a transfer: pay a small known cost now so a huge unknown cost does not wreck you later.
Buy for devastating, hard-to-recover losses. Pay out of pocket for survivable annoyances.
Devastating: unable to work for a year in your 30s. A partner dies young with small kids and shared housing costs. You cause a serious crash and are sued. A rental fire hurts neighbours.
Survivable: a cracked phone screen, a $200 filling, a delayed flight, a warranty on a $600 appliance.
Why insurance makes sense even though, on average, you lose money. Insurers must collect more in premiums than they pay in claims, to cover costs and profit, so the average buyer gets back less than they paid. That is expected.
It still makes sense for catastrophes: $1 matters far more when you are ruined than when you are comfortable (diminishing marginal utility). Paying $30 a month you barely notice to avoid a $40,000 liability claim or a year with no paycheque trades cheap dollars for precious dollars.
The skip-small rule: if you could pay for the loss from the starter $1,500–$2,500 buffer (see the buffer ladder) or one month of savings without debt, do not insure it. Insure what would force debt, wipe out savings, or cut years off the plan.
Beginners often get this backwards: they skip the big stuff because it feels uncomfortable, and over-buy small stuff at checkout. Skip or postpone: lender mortgage life before comparing portable term (see life insurance), checkout warranties as a habit, investment-linked insurance you cannot explain, and heavy small-item coverage while disability, liability, or term gaps sit empty.
No-BS rules:
- Many employers provide life, disability (short and long term), health, dental, vision, and an Employee Assistance Program (EAP — workplace counselling, unrelated to education-plan payments). Treat that as a start, not a plan. Group amounts often have caps and waiting periods, and coverage can end or shrink on leave, layoff, or job change. You cannot take it with you.
- Know your booklet, including the group-life conversion privilege: usually 31 days after coverage ends to convert to an individual policy with no new health checks (verify in your booklet). Top up thin spots with convertible term or non-cancellable disability only after reading definitions.
- Definitions matter more than brand names. Two policies with the same monthly amount can pay very differently.
- If you cannot explain a product in two sentences, do not buy it yet.
- Answer every application question fully, and keep an old policy until its replacement is in force. For two years, a life or disability insurer can generally void a policy over an important wrong or missing answer (over fraud, at any time). A new policy restarts that clock.
- Review every 2–3 years or at a trigger, not monthly.
Assess life and disability separately (see disability first and life insurance); some households need both. If premiums squeeze out essentials or TFSA or RRSP saving, check what you actually need and what work already covers. A tight budget is a reason to review, not proof you are over-insured. Long-term-care insurance is a later-life specialist topic, with no fixed age to buy it.
Story — Farah.
Illustration — fictional people and numbers.
Farah, 29, rents, has no kids, and has basic group benefits. No one depends on her, so her biggest risk is not dying but a year with no paycheque from illness or injury. She reads her group disability booklet first and builds emergency savings before shopping for anything exotic.