Over-contribution traps
Where beginners get burned.
By Leo HongReviewed 2 min read
CRA is strict about over-contributions. Details change, but patterns repeat:
- TFSA: re-contributing a withdrawal in the same year. Say your TFSA is full. You withdraw $10,000 in June and put it back in September: same money, right? Not to CRA. The room returns next January, so September’s deposit is an excess unless other unused room covers it. The penalty is 1% a month on the excess until you remove it.
- TFSA: not tracking multiple institutions. You hold one TFSA at an online bank and another at a discount brokerage. Each says you can contribute. CRA adds them together. You over-contribute.
- TFSA: treating it as a trading account. CRA can tax day-trading or frequent buying and selling inside a TFSA as business income, and certain prohibited or over-concentrated holdings trigger extra taxes. Buying and holding broad funds keeps you safely within the rules (check unusual cases).
- The transfer itself can be the trap. Moves between institutions must be direct (trustee-to-trustee) transfers. Withdrawing and redepositing counts as a TFSA withdrawal (room back next year) and a new contribution (possible over-contribution this year). An RRSP cashed out along the way triggers withholding as if it were income. Always have the receiving institution do the transfer directly.
- RRSP: exceeding by more than the small buffer. There is a $2,000 lifetime buffer if you are 18+. Excess beyond it is generally taxed at 1% a month until removed, reported on a T1-OVP (a special return to report and pay it). Do not use the buffer as a strategy.
- FHSA: maxing blindly. FHSA and RRSP room interact in ways that are not obvious (see account rules in detail). Check before any transfer.
- RESP: not fatal but wasteful. Contributions beyond $50,000 per beneficiary face penalty tax. Money past the grant limits earns no extra grant.
- Leaving Canada. Contributions while non-resident can be penalized, and other countries may tax these accounts differently (see account rules in detail).
- Deadline myths. RRSP: to deduct against last year, contribute within the first 60 days of this year (typically). FHSA: December 31, no extension. TFSA: no deadline; room works by calendar year. Missing the RRSP deadline does not lose room; it just moves the deduction year.
No-BS principle: automate contributions below your confirmed room, leave a $200–$500 buffer if you have multiple accounts, and do a December room check before topping up.