MER, fees, and SPIVA
Why costs predict more than picks.
By Leo HongReviewed 1 min read
MER (management expense ratio): the yearly % a fund takes (first met in Canadian accounts; other costs below). A 2% MER on $100,000 is ~$2,000 a year, whether markets rise or fall.
Other costs: trading expense ratio (TER — the fund’s trading costs as a percentage of assets), taxes, bid-ask spreads (the gap between buying and selling prices), cash drag (growth forgone while money sits uninvested), and advisory fees.
Note
SPIVA (S&P Indices vs Active)
Twice-yearly scorecards compare active funds (managers picking investments) with benchmarks, the indexes for their markets. The finding holds across years and countries, including Canada: after fees, most active funds trail their benchmark over 5 and 10 years, and longer where measured. Some win short-term, but few keep winning, and spotting them in advance is the hard part.
Why most active funds fail: a higher MER, turnover (frequent buying and selling) and its taxes, style drift (moving away from the stated approach), manager changes, winners that are hard to spot in advance and rarely last, and closet indexing (charging active fees for index-like holdings). The fee gap compounds against you, however clever the picks. (The theory behind this, the efficient market hypothesis, is in investing background.)
Illustrative costs:
- HISA: 0% MER but opportunity cost.
- GIC: 0% MER, locked.
- Canadian aggregate bond fund: ~0.09% MER.
- Asset-allocation ETF: ~0.20% MER.
- Average Canadian equity mutual fund: ~1.5–2.5% MER.
Same market, different fees. Over decades, that gap is the retirement.
Sources
- S&P Dow Jones Indices — SPIVA Canada scorecards · spglobal.com