The five ways Canadians get help
From DIY to a full-service advisor: what each one does and costs.
By Leo HongReviewed 4 min read
1. DIY self-directed. You open a discount brokerage account and run everything yourself: contributions, mix, rebalancing, taxes. With no advice fee, cost is low, but you pay with time and you own the mistakes. Many discount brokerages charge $0 per trade. When comparing brokerages, check Canadian Investor Protection Fund (CIPF) membership, account and inactivity fees, ETF trading costs, the registered accounts you need, and support for automatic purchases.
2. Robo-advisor. You answer risk questions, then software puts you in a diversified portfolio, rebalances it, and handles tax slips and transfers. Typical all-in cost is about 0.6–0.7% a year: roughly 0.50% for management plus a 0.10–0.20% fund fee. Management fees drop at higher balances (check the current schedule). Tax, retirement, estate, or cross-border planning usually needs separate help.
3. Advice-only (fee-only) planner. You pay a flat fee or hourly rate for a plan, then you carry it out yourself, usually in low-cost ETFs you own (see what it costs to invest). This type doesn’t manage your money, hold assets, or take product commissions. Complex cases cost more than the table’s figures, and later updates usually cost less than the first plan.
Where to find one: FP Canada Find a Planner (directory, not endorsement), advice-only directories, and referrals from DIY communities. They may call themselves financial advisor, financial planner, or Certified Financial Planner (CFP). Check the credential with the body that issues it (FP Canada for the CFP), get fee-only status in writing, and never hire by title alone. A planner who sells and manages nothing may hold no securities registration, so a registration search may show no record.
4. Mutual fund dealer. The person behind the desk at your local bank branch. Convenient and familiar, but often limited to the bank’s own (proprietary) funds. Many are registered with the Canadian Investment Regulatory Organization (CIRO) to sell mutual funds only, so they generally cannot recommend ETFs or stocks at a discount brokerage. Pay often includes trailers, which are legal but shape incentives.
5. AUM-based wealth manager. You hand over decisions and pay a yearly percentage of the balance managed, plus fund fees inside the holdings. These managers work at bank private-wealth arms, full-service brokerages, and independent firms, including insurer-affiliated sellers. For a $100,000–$500,000 account, the advice fee is roughly 1% of assets a year, stepping down above that. Then add the fund fees, the management expense ratio (MER, the annual fund fee): about 0.2% for index funds, 1% or more for active funds. Some providers push costs higher with high-MER in-house funds and insurance add-ons.
Titles vary (advisor, planner, wealth manager, portfolio manager), so check registration, credentials such as Chartered Financial Analyst (CFA) or CFP, and what the service covers. A good manager explains how to leave.
The five types at a glance (illustrative; all-in cost per year):
| Type | How you pay | Typical cost | Fits when |
|---|---|---|---|
| DIY self-directed | Your time; no advice fee | ~0.2% all-in (about $200 per $100,000) | You are organized and keep it to one simple holding per account |
| Robo-advisor | A management fee on your balance, plus fund fees | ~0.6–0.7% all-in (about $600–$700 per $100,000) | You want automation and no rebalancing |
| Advice-only (fee-only) planner | A flat fee or hourly rate | First year: $1,500–$5,000 flat or $150–$500 per hour; later: ~$1,000–$2,000 per refresh | You want a checkup every few years or before a big move |
| Mutual fund dealer | Trailers inside the fund fee | ~1.5–2.5% all-in (about $1,500–$2,500 per $100,000) | You want convenience, accepting an in-house fund shelf |
| AUM-based wealth manager | A yearly percentage of your balance, plus fund fees | ~1–2% all-in (about $1,000–$2,000 per $100,000) | Complex tax, business, cross-border, estate, or family needs, or coaching you will actually use |
Note
Commission vs fee
Commission means the product company pays the seller when you buy, for example through a yearly trailer inside the fund fee. You do not write a cheque, but you pay every year inside the fund. Fee means you pay the helper directly (flat, hourly, or a percentage of assets), with no pay from anyone else. Whoever pays gets served first, so convert both to dollars per year on your balance.
Fee-only means paid only by you, with no trailers, commissions, bonuses, or referral pay. Fee-based means you pay a fee (often a percentage of assets) and the helper may also earn commissions or other product pay. Ask in plain words what else they receive if you follow their advice, and get the answer in a short letter you can keep.
A title proves little. Ontario (since 2022) and New Brunswick (since January 1, 2026, with transition periods to 2028–2030 for people already using the titles) restrict “financial planner” and “financial advisor”. Quebec has its own system (check the Autorité des marchés financiers, AMF). Saskatchewan’s law is waiting for regulations. Elsewhere, check your province. Most people who call themselves “advisor” owe you no blanket fiduciary duty (a legal duty to put your interests ahead of their own in everything they do). Registered firms and reps do owe two specific duties under the Client Focused Reforms: resolve material conflicts in your best interest, and put your interest first when judging whether a product suits you. Both are narrower than a general fiduciary duty. Hire by registration, credential, pay structure, and fit. AreTheyRegistered.ca shows registration; save a screenshot of the result.
Sources
- FP Canada — Find a Planner · financialplanningforcanadians.ca
- AreTheyRegistered.ca · aretheyregistered.ca