Advisor vs DIY
Do-it-yourself vs paid help: the five ways Canadians get help, what it really costs, red flags, and five questions to ask.
4 articles · about 8 min in all
About this topic
What this topic covers: five ways Canadians get help and their pricing (see the five ways Canadians get help), yearly cost checks and red flags (see what it really costs), and five asks that expose a sales pitch (see the five asks).
How to read it: skim the five types and their pricing, copy the five asks as they are, and if you already have a helper, use the fee patterns and red flags.
You sit across from a friendly person at the bank. Coffee, smile, a printout with your name on it. It feels like advice. Sometimes it is. Sometimes it is a sale wearing advice clothes.
This topic helps you tell the difference, in plain language, anywhere in Canada.
There is no single job called financial advisor. The same word covers very different jobs, pay, and incentives. Once you see how someone is paid, what they can sell, and how to check them, the meeting gets much calmer.
The trade-off: do-it-yourself (DIY) investing keeps fees low, but your own behaviour can cost you: panic selling, chasing performance, timing the market, pausing contributions. Automation, low-cost index funds, and a written IPS (your investing rule sheet) reduce those mistakes. An advisor is worth it when the help you actually get with behaviour, complexity, or life events is worth more than the fee. The five ways Canadians get help has the cost of each type; what it costs to invest gives the short version.
Author’s take
For most readers of this guide, DIY wins, alone or with a fee-only checkup now and then. If you want help, hire a fee-only, advice-only planner: flat or hourly, no commissions, no trailers (yearly sales commissions paid from inside fund fees), and you carry out the plan. Avoid commission-based sellers and ongoing assets-under-management (AUM) managers unless complexity or behaviour clearly justifies the cost every year.
When you have read it
Take the five asks to your next meeting (see the five asks), verify registration and conflicts (see the five ways Canadians get help), and compare the annual dollar cost with the service received (see what it really costs). Review exit terms and tax consequences before making a change.
Educational only, not personal advice. Rules and limits change; verify with the official source before acting. Types only, with no specific providers and no product recommendations; numbers are illustrations. Send feedback.
Start readingThe five ways Canadians get helpNext topic: Protect