Foreign exchange and withholding tax
The 15% you cannot reclaim in a TFSA.
By Leo HongReviewed 1 min read
If you hold U.S. stocks or U.S.-listed ETFs, the U.S. generally withholds tax on dividends paid to Canadian residents. Which account holds them matters: in a TFSA, that 15% is lost for good, while an RRSP is generally exempt under the tax treaty for U.S.-listed holdings. Most beginners can stop after the next paragraph.
Principle, not panic: as a beginner, do not build your portfolio around withholding. A ~1.5% U.S. dividend yield × 15% ≈ 0.2% drag on that holding. That is real, but moving to a fund with a lower management expense ratio (MER, the annual fund fee; MER, fees, and SPIVA) can save more. Prefer Canadian-listed broad funds for simplicity. For large U.S. holdings later, weigh the RRSP’s withholding advantage against currency-conversion costs and your overall account plan, and track foreign tax credits in taxable accounts.
The account-by-account withholding rules, the W-8BEN form, and currency-conversion costs are in account rules in detail; tracking your adjusted cost base and the attribution rules are in tax details beyond the basics.