Skip to content
Canadian Money Guide

Big purchases

Home in Canada

Rent vs buy without fairy tales.

By Leo HongReviewed 7 min read

On this page

Renting is not throwing money away. Buying is not automatic winning.#

Rent buys shelter, flexibility, and a predictable maximum cost. A mortgage buys forced savings, control, and a borrowed-money bet on one street in one city. It also brings interest, tax, maintenance, and risk.

Both can build wealth. Math and life stage decide, not slogans.

Rent-vs-buy principles:

  • Compare all-in to all-in. Compare the full cost of owning with renting plus investing the difference. Owners forget property tax, insurance, maintenance, condo fees, higher utilities, and closing costs spread over the years they stay. Renters forget rent increases, moves, and the forced saving they miss. Judge by after-tax net worth when the stay ends, never by the monthly payment.
  • Time matters. Selling within 2–3 years of buying usually loses to the churn tax (see cars), plus default insurance if you put under 20% down and a break penalty if you cannot port (move) the mortgage. Stays of 7–10+ years spread these costs out.
  • Life matters more. Job mobility, relationship stability, kid and school needs, health, and your appetite for home repairs all count. A perfect spreadsheet with a miserable commute is a bad buy.
  • Simple gut check. If owning costs 40–60%+ more than renting a similar home and you would reliably invest the gap, renting and investing often does well. Money for a committed purchase follows the time-left schedule; otherwise, invest the gap as long-term savings. If owning costs about the same as rent and you will stay 7+ years with stable income, buying often makes sense.

You may have heard of the “5% rule”: owning costs about 5% of the price a year, so buy if rent is above (5% × price) ÷ 12; otherwise rent. Skip it. One fixed number cannot capture your investment return, tax rate, or length of stay.

Use the method instead (my rent-vs-buy calculator — educational, not advice). Each year, the renter invests whatever owning costs above their rent (mortgage payment, property tax, maintenance, insurance). When the stay ends, the buyer pays selling costs and the mortgage; the renter pays capital-gains tax on the invested savings. More after-tax net worth, at your inputs, wins.

Run your own numbers before any offer: 10 focused minutes with the tool above beats every slogan, including this article’s.

Author’s take

Renting and investing the gap is underrated. Buy for lifestyle and stability first, not because owning builds more wealth. Run both numbers; let the math, not beliefs, decide.

Down payment and mortgage insurance in plain English#

Minimum down payments for a home you will live in (general rules; lenders and insurers can be stricter, so check current ones):

  • Up to $500,000: 5% down
  • Over $500,000 and below $1.5 million: 5% of the first $500,000 + 10% of the rest
  • $1.5 million or more: no default insurance (the price cap rose to $1.5 million on December 15, 2024), so the minimum down is 20%

Example: a $650,000 home = $25,000 (5% of the first $500,000) + $15,000 (10% of the remaining $150,000) = $40,000 minimum down, or ~6.15%.

If your down payment is under 20%, you generally need mortgage default insurance from the Canada Mortgage and Housing Corporation (CMHC), Sagen, or Canada Guaranty. It protects the lender, but you pay the premium. The premium depends on the loan-to-value (LTV) ratio: the loan as a share of the price. CMHC’s standard owner-occupied premiums are:

  • 80.01–85% LTV: 2.8%
  • 85.01–90% LTV: 3.1%
  • 90.01–95% LTV: 4.0% (4.5% with a non-traditional down payment)

CMHC also adds a 0.20% surcharge for amortizations (total payoff periods) over 25 years. Check the current insurer schedule. For example, a $600,000 mortgage at 90.01–95% LTV with a 4% premium adds $24,000 to the loan. In some provinces (Ontario and Quebec, for example), you pay provincial sales tax on the premium in cash at closing; check your province.

Illustration only — premium grids vary by down payment and amortization.

Note

Insured-buyer extras Verify current rules

Insured first-time buyers (any home) and insured buyers of newly built homes can get 30-year amortizations (rules effective December 15, 2024); other insured buyers get 25 years. First-time buyers of new builds get Goods and Services Tax (GST) relief: up to 100% of the GST (~$50,000 max) on homes up to $1 million, phasing out to $1.5 million, for purchase agreements dated on or after March 20, 2025.

Default insurance lets you buy sooner with less down, but it raises the mortgage balance and interest.

A bigger down payment is not automatically better either. Empty your emergency fund to reach 20%, and you are house-poor (all your money is in the house) the day the furnace dies and a new one costs $9,000. Keep 3–6 months of essentials (see emergency fund, credit scores, and killing debt) plus closing cash separate from the down payment.

Stress test: qualify at higher than you pay#

Federally regulated lenders must test you at the higher of your contract rate + 2% or the benchmark floor, which regulators call the minimum qualifying rate (MQR; reference figures for 2026). This proves you can survive rate rises.

So you qualify for less than your contract rate alone would allow. That protects you.

Lenders also use two debt-service limits:

  • Gross debt service (GDS): housing costs ÷ gross (pre-tax) income. About 39% is the official cap for insured loans (lenders often approve less; check).
  • Total debt service (TDS): all debts including housing ÷ gross income. About 44% is the official cap (check).

Qualifying for $700,000 does not mean you can afford it with daycare, a car, and the rest of life. Choose a payment you can carry at higher rates, plus maintenance, on one income if that is the plan.

Fixed vs variable — principles only, not a prediction:

  • Fixed: certainty, usually a higher starting rate, and a bigger penalty to break early (interest rate differential, or IRD, charges can sting). Good if you need a budget that lets you sleep.
  • Variable: moves with the prime rate (how rates move: Investing background); usually cheaper over long cycles, but painful when rates jump. The penalty is often just 3 months’ interest. Good if you have a buffer and flexibility. Ask whether the payment changes with prime or stays fixed. With a fixed payment, a rate rise stretches your payoff, and past the “trigger rate” the payment no longer covers the interest.
  • Hybrid (split): part fixed, part variable — a middle ground.

The term (the years until you renew the contract, not the amortization), prepayment privileges (lump sums and payment increases), portability, and the penalty formula matter as much as the rate. A 0.1% rate difference is small next to a $12,000 penalty or no right to prepay.

Get quotes from a mortgage broker and a bank. Compare the annual percentage rate (APR), penalties, and features, not just the advertised rate.

Renewal and prepayment#

Your mortgage term ends long before the loan does, so you will renew several times. Federally regulated lenders must send a renewal statement at least 21 days before the term ends (check the rules for provincially regulated lenders). Do not just sign it. Start comparing well before it arrives: ask your lender for its best rate, get one outside quote, and compare penalties and prepayment privileges, not only the rate. You can move to another lender at renewal. At federally regulated lenders, a straight switch of an uninsured mortgage (same balance, same amortization) is generally exempt from the stress test (check current rules).

Prepay or invest? Use the debt line in priority order. Paying down a mortgage above roughly 6–7% is a guaranteed saving that usually beats optional investing. Below that, it is a judgment call that depends on the rate, how long the money could stay invested, and your risk ceiling. First take any employer match and fill both the starter buffer and the full emergency fund, because you cannot get prepaid principal back without borrowing again. Then use your prepayment privileges instead of paying a penalty.

Closing 3–5% + carrying 2–4%/yr: the forgotten math#

Closing: budget 3–5% of price in cash beyond the down payment.

  • Land transfer tax, which varies hugely by province: British Columbia calls it “Property Transfer Tax”; Ontario has a provincial tax plus a Toronto one; Alberta and Saskatchewan charge smaller fees instead
  • Legal $1,500–$2,500
  • Title insurance $300–$500
  • Home inspection $500–$700, appraisal $300–$500
  • Moving $1,000–$3,000, utility hookups, immediate repairs
  • Prepaid tax and adjustments, condo status certificate (the condo’s legal and financial snapshot; some provinces call it an estoppel certificate), survey if needed

$600,000 × 4% = $24,000 in cash. First-time-buyer rebates and credits help in some provinces and cities but do not erase it. If you do not have the down payment, closing cash, and 3–6 months of essentials set aside, you are not ready yet, and that is okay.

Illustration only — transfer tax and fees vary by province/city.

Carrying: budget 2–4% of home value per year for true ownership.

  • 1–2% maintenance reserve (roof, furnace, windows, plumbing — not if, but when). More for an older home or harsh climate.
  • Property tax 0.5–1.5%, depending on city/province
  • Home insurance $100–$250/mo
  • Utilities bump + condo fees if applicable

A $600,000 home × 3% = $18,000 a year, or $1,500 a month on top of the mortgage. That is why a $2,800 mortgage payment feels like $4,300. Budget for it before you make an offer. The fill-in is in home all-in cost worksheet.

Illustration only — tax, insurance, and maintenance vary.

First-home accounts: FHSA and the Home Buyers’ Plan — the short version#

Full account rules live in the one-page map and priority order and account rules in detail. The decision:

Note

First-home money

An FHSA first if you qualify (a deduction like an RRSP, a tax-free qualifying withdrawal like a TFSA), then a TFSA, then an RRSP withdrawal under the Home Buyers’ Plan (HBP) if it fits. You can use the FHSA and the HBP for the same home.

None of these makes an unaffordable home affordable. They only cut tax.

Checklist#

Time: 60 min

  • All-in own vs all-in rent + invest gap compared for a 7–10 yr stay, not just mortgage vs rent
  • Down payment + default insurance premium understood; 20% not at cost of zero emergency
  • Pre-approval based on stress test + GDS/TDS; payment survivable if rates +2%; if any test fails, lower the price or keep renting
  • Closing 3–5% cash + carrying 2–4%/yr budgeted beyond mortgage
  • FHSA/HBP decision made (full account rules in Canadian accounts); fixed vs variable chosen for buffer + sleep, not prediction

Sources

Educational only, not personal advice. Rules and limits change; verify with the official source before acting.

Spotted a mistake, or have a question? Tell me.