Don’t speculate
Stock picking, crypto, leverage.
By Leo HongReviewed 3 min read
Re-read this article before you do anything impulsive.
Stock picking: To beat a broad index consistently after fees and taxes, you must be right about business, price, timing, and your own emotions. You must stay right for decades, against professionals with faster data. SPIVA shows most pros fail. Your edge as an amateur with a phone is not insight. It is patience and low costs. If you love research, keep a journal, track 3-year returns against a benchmark after taxes and fees, and be honest. Most who do quit picking. Think of hyped stock tips as lottery tickets: exciting, cheap to enter, almost never building wealth. Quiet millionaires hold boring ETFs: own everything, pay little, wait decades. Pick your game accordingly.
Watch out
Technical vs fundamental: do not assume an edge
Technical analysis times trades from past price patterns. Fundamental analysis values businesses from financial statements and forecasts. Neither has been shown to give an individual investor a repeatable edge after costs. Author’s take: skip both and own a broad low-cost index fund.
Sector and country bets — stock picking in the ETF era. The pick hides inside the fund: a banks ETF, an AI theme, or a U.S.-only slice is still one opinion and one concentrated bet. It sits on top of stocks your whole-market core already holds (see simple portfolios). A sector or theme has no higher expected return than the whole market, only more risk, and writing it into your IPS does not change that. Keep the ~20–30% Canada default and let your broad funds set every other weight.
Crypto: volatile, traded 24/7, and driven by stories. It carries custody risk (losing access through a hacked exchange or lost keys) and tax complexity: each trade, swap, or purchase can be taxable. For retirement savings it has no reliable expected return you can plan around. Skip it and own productive assets you can hold for decades instead.
Leverage: buying on margin (with money borrowed from your broker) and other borrowing to invest, including the Smith Manoeuvre (borrowing against home equity to invest, popular in Canada). This guide’s default: no leverage. It magnifies losses, can trigger margin calls (the broker forces a sale at the worst moment), and can turn a temporary dip into a permanent loss. Modest leverage can be justified for a few people with stable high income, large buffers, long horizons, and professional oversight. That is an individual call, never the default. Researchers disagree on whether modest leverage pays, so the cautious default is a judgment.
Dividends — focus on total return: a dividend is not free money. The share price drops by the amount paid out, so total return (price change plus payouts) is what counts, not yield. Chasing yield adds specific risk (see risk done right). In a taxable account, Canadian dividends get a gross-up and a dividend tax credit. The gross-up raises your net income, which can reduce income-tested benefits (the OAS clawback, for example), so choose the account for your whole plan, not the credit alone.
Also avoid: switching mixes on forecasts, structured products (hidden fees, capped gains), and strategies that win in backtests and fail in real markets.
Factor investing — contested, and evidence is not a promise: size, value, momentum, and profitability are studied as sources of extra return. But future premiums are uncertain, costs matter, and lagging the market can last a decade. Author’s take: hold the broad market with no factor tilt. Simpler, cheaper, and easier to stick with.
What to do instead:
- Own the market with 1–2 broad funds.
- Keep all-in costs within the cost bars in what it costs to invest unless planning value justifies more.
- Contribute every pay, rebalance by bands, ignore forecasts.
- Take risk in allocation (more equity if horizon allows), not in concentration or borrowing.
If a tip comes with urgency (“act now, private deal, guaranteed 12%”), it is a sales pitch or a scam. Real investing is boring: automatic, diversified, low-cost, long. Boring compounds.
Note
Examples and resources Illustrations, not endorsements
- Vanguard asset-allocation ETFs as one-fund examples
- Planning returns: FP Canada and IQPF’s yearly Projection Assumption Guidelines, used by many Canadian planners; cross-check PWL Capital’s Financial Planning Assumptions or RBC’s forecasts
Sources
- Vanguard Canada — asset-allocation ETF pages · vanguard.ca
- FP Canada · fpcanada.ca
- PWL Capital · pwlcapital.com
- RBC capital-market assumptions · rbcgam.com