Hating loss
Loss aversion: “Losing $1,000 hurts more than gaining $1,000 feels good.”
By Leo HongReviewed 2 min read
Research on loss aversion finds that a loss hurts about twice as much as an equal gain feels good. That imbalance skews when you sell and what you keep.
Story — The oil stock in the drawer in Calgary.
Illustration — fictional people and numbers.
Marc, 45, held an energy stock his family loved. It fell 35%. He waited for it to “come back.” It fell more. Meanwhile, he sold his steady diversified winner early to pay for a truck. He kept what no longer fit and sold what did.
1. Loss aversion — pain speaks louder than gain. Sitting in cash for years after a scare can cost tens of thousands in missed growth on a $100,000 portfolio. Fix: decide your mix when calm, then let calm-you guide queasy-you.
2. Disposition effect — “Sell winners fast, ride losers forever.” Taking a gain feels like winning. Taking a loss feels like failing. In a taxable account (where you pay tax on gains when you sell), you trigger tax early and waste losses that could cut your tax. Fix: “Would I buy this today at this price for this job in my plan?” If no, sell, up or down. What you paid is history.
3. Sunk-cost + regret — “I have put in so much, I can’t quit / what if I am wrong?” It combines framing bias (the same loss feels smaller when the story changes) with freezing up from shame. You add another $5,000 to defend an old choice you would not make today. Fix: “From today forward, where does the next dollar work hardest?” Write down when you will review a position and what would make it unsuitable. For the diversified portfolio, use your investment policy statement (IPS), the one-page investing rule sheet in simple portfolios. A price drop alone does not change the plan.
Two crash tales: Theo sold everything for cash and watched the rebound from outside the market (recency and loss aversion). Amara sold mid-crash and bought back well after the recovery: selling low, buying high (regret and action bias). Both would have kept more by simply holding and rebalancing by their bands.
Avoid / Keep / Do — hating loss:
- Avoid: panic-to-cash sales, defending a sunk story with new money, riding a personal favourite past the point it fits your plan.
- Keep: band rebalancing (it trims winners after they rise, whatever your mood), the prewritten crash plan, the buddy call (one steady person you call first; systems that actually work) before any big move.
- Do (this week): fill in the blank now: “If my portfolio drops 20% this year, I will ___.” Use the IPS template and put your buddy’s number in the same note.
Losses are tuition if you learn. They are rent if you repeat.