Too sure
Overconfidence: “I’ve got this figured out.”
By Leo HongReviewed 4 min read
Confidence feels like an edge. Often it is just comfort.
Story — The engineer in Waterloo who beat the market (for 18 months).
Illustration — fictional people and numbers.
Dev, 29, tested a “quant strategy” on past data, then ran it with real money and beat his simple fund for 18 months. He bet bigger, added borrowed money to “catch up” when it lagged, then faced a forced sale at the worst time. Smart and careful, but up against people who do this full time.
His cousin went further. Early day-trading wins felt like skill, so he quit the boring fund and traded daily. Then he lost his gains plus savings: a hard lesson that luck is not a strategy (overconfidence, self-attribution, and hindsight). The boring index fund won without trying.
1. Overconfidence — “I am above average (like everyone else).” Extra trading and big concentrated bets leak money to costs and taxes. Even $50 a month in trading costs adds up to thousands over the years. Fix: keep a short decision journal: what you expect, why, and when you will admit you are wrong. Review yearly.
2. Confirmation bias — “I only read what agrees with me.” Feeds serve you 40 videos proving you are right. You feel researched. You have only heard one side. Fix: before any big move, write the best three arguments against it.
3. Anchoring — “It was $120, now $70 — what a deal!” You judge by the old number, not by fit. A stock down 50% can still be expensive. Fix: “Would this price make sense if I had never seen the old price?”
4. Survivorship bias — “My cousin picked a winner, so it works.” You see the winners (funded startups, star funds, one lucky coin-flipper who got famous) and miss the failures. A backtest that drops failed funds makes the strategy look better. Compare results that include them, such as the active-fund scorecards in MER, fees, and SPIVA. A broad index fund is different: it holds the losers too, all the way down until they are removed, so its returns already include the failures.
5. Need-to-do-something — “Don’t just stand there.” In a fall, doing nothing feels careless, so people sell to feel useful. For example, after a 30–40% fall, selling a holding worth $50,000 before the drop locks in a $15,000–$20,000 loss. Holding through the recovery can erase it. Fix: make inaction the default: “I do nothing except keep contributing.”
Where overconfidence costs most: picking stocks. The usual path: you see a few years of strong returns and decide a global index fund at ~6–7% a year (see basics in plain language) is too low. You move into individual stocks, options (bets on price moves), or crypto to “catch up.” Three facts explain why that usually backfires.
Extra risk you could have diversified away is not paid. Expected return is the average yearly return you could reasonably expect over many possible futures for the risk you take. Standard deviation measures how widely actual yearly returns scatter around that average. The wider the scatter, the bigger both the wins and the losses. Stocks as a group scatter more than bonds, and that market-wide risk earns a higher expected return (see risk done right). A single stock adds more scatter. That extra part is risk specific to one company, and owning everything removes it for free, so the market does not pay you for it. So a single stock is not expected to beat the market. It has a wider range of outcomes, and many people end up at the bad end.
Most stocks lag cash, and a handful of winners drive the gains. Hendrik Bessembinder’s research (“Do Stocks Outperform Treasury Bills?”, 2018) found that about 57% of U.S. stocks from 1926 to 2016 failed to beat Treasury bills (short-term U.S. government debt, close to cash) over their lifetimes. A 2023 global follow-up with co-authors found the same pattern worldwide. From 1990 to 2020, the top 2.4% of stocks created all of the net wealth. A broad index fund owns those winners automatically. A handful of picks probably does not, and you cannot know in advance which ones will.
Trading more makes it worse. Brad Barber and Terrance Odean (“Trading Is Hazardous to Your Wealth”, 2000) tracked tens of thousands of U.S. households at a discount broker in the 1990s. The households that traded most earned 11.4% a year, while the market returned 17.9%. The authors blame overconfident, frequent trading and its costs.
Picking is not a skill you can safely assume you have. The full case is in don’t speculate.
Avoid / Keep / Do — too sure:
- Avoid: big bets on backtested strategies, catch-up trades with borrowed money, picking individual stocks to beat the index, any purchase decided in under a day.
- Keep: the decision journal, the whole-market portfolio, and a fixed hobby-spending cap if you experiment outside the funded plan.
- Do (this week): before your next excited buy, write the three best arguments against it. If you can’t fill them in 10 minutes, you haven’t researched. You’ve shopped.
Boredom is a feature. One simple holding per account means less room for cleverness to hurt you.
Sources
- Bessembinder — Do Stocks Outperform Treasury Bills? (2018) · news.wpcarey.asu.edu
- Barber and Odean — Trading Is Hazardous to Your Wealth (2000) · faculty.haas.berkeley.edu