Skip to content
Canadian Money Guide

Investing

The behaviour gap

The return you give away.

By Leo HongReviewed 2 min read

Investors usually earn less than the funds they own, mostly because of when they buy and sell. The size of the gap varies by period and fund type. Part of any gap comes from regular contributions and rebalancing, not mistakes.

What the research shows. Morningstar’s Mind the Gap study (2026 edition) compares what U.S. funds returned with what their investors earned, allowing for when money went in and out. In the 10 years to December 2025, the funds returned about 8.7% a year and their investors about 9.9%. That is a gap of 1.2 percentage point a year. Other editions find gaps of a similar size. The data is American and counts every fund, so treat it as the typical size of the leak, not a forecast for you.

One common cause is chasing last decade’s winners, or a hotter return than a global index fund offers. Chasing heat and too sure explain why that backfires.

Time in the market beats timing the market. Timing means being right twice: when to sell and when to buy back. The best days tend to come right after the worst ones, so anyone who sells in a fall is likely to miss part of the rebound. Cash waiting outside the market earns less than staying invested, and frequent moves add taxes, spreads, and fees.

Note

Lump sum vs dollar-cost averaging (DCA)

DCA means investing on a fixed schedule. If you have a lump sum, investing it all now usually beats adding it bit by bit. Markets rise more often than not, so earlier beats later. For most people, DCA is simply investing each payday’s surplus (income minus expenses) once the emergency fund is full. Automate it, every pay, no timing. If investing it all at once is more than you can calmly hold, a short preset schedule written into your IPS is a fair compromise. Holding cash to wait for a dip is not.

Common leaks in working years:

  • Pausing contributions in crashes. In 2008, 2020, and 2022, each pause missed the rebound that drives long-term averages.
  • Switching strategies yearly. Value, then growth, then crypto, then cash. Each switch resets compounding.
  • Checking daily. Daily noise leads to anxiety, and anxiety to trading. Monthly or quarterly is plenty for long-term money.
  • Mental accounting mess. Five accounts with five strategies add up to no strategy.

Fixes that work (Behaviour has the full set): follow your IPS and keep the long-term portfolio simple, with no satellites. If you experiment, use a fixed hobby-spending cap outside the funded plan, not a second investment strategy.

Low fees and staying invested beat brilliance.

Sources

Educational only, not personal advice. Rules and limits change; verify with the official source before acting. Fund mentions are illustrations of a type, not recommendations. Figures are for 2026.

Spotted a mistake, or have a question? Tell me.