Chasing heat
Performance chasing: “Everyone’s getting rich but me.”
By Leo HongReviewed 3 min read
Watch out
Reality check
Out of 100 Canadians who chased last year’s winner, how many beat a simple diversified portfolio after fees and taxes over 10 years? The research in MER, fees, and SPIVA and the behaviour gap says: few. Low fees last; heat does not. Choose by low fees and breadth, never by last year’s winner.
Story — The driveway party in Oakville.
Illustration — fictional people and numbers.
Nadia, 32, had a simple balanced portfolio that was doing its job. Then in 2021, cousins, co-workers, and videos all pitched winners. Her boring holding felt embarrassing. She bought each winner after months of gains. By 2022, the hot half was down sharply. The boring half recovered.
She did not lose to the market. She lost to market timing.
The same story repeated through the 2020s: AI chips and memory, bitcoin, gold, crowd favourites, hot new listings.
1. Recency bias — “What just happened keeps happening.” You turn 5 to 10 great years into “forever” and buy at the top. Fix: keep the boring core. Past performance does not predict the future. Check long-term history and capital-market assumptions (return forecasts) for that asset class.
2. FOMO (fear of missing out) — “If I wait, I am left behind.” Rushed buys are always too big: $10,000 on a tip hurts far more than $500 of fun money. Fix: sleep on it and check your plan. Automatic payday contributions keep running. Only surprise buys wait.
3. Herding — “Everyone can’t be wrong.” When popularity is highest, high hopes are already in the price, so future returns are often lowest. Fix: ask “Who is happily selling to me, and why?”
4. Big-story trap — “This story makes sense, so it must make money.” It combines social-media hype, vivid headlines, and confusing a good company with a good stock. A trend can be real and still pay poorly if the price already assumes perfection. Fix: ask “Is the trend real?” apart from “Is the price already assuming it succeeds perfectly?” Only the second decides your return.
Recency in numbers: the last decade is not a forecast. Many people see the S&P 500 (about 500 large U.S. companies) earn about 14–15% a year over the decade to 2025, and the Nasdaq-100 (100 large, mostly technology companies) nearly 20%, in U.S. dollars with dividends reinvested. They expect the same for the next 30 years. They should not. Part of a run like that can come from prices rising faster than company earnings, which cannot go on forever, and part from a few very large winners (see too sure).
The same mistake shows up in housing: “house prices rise 5% a year” is not a safe planning assumption. Canadian prices have beaten incomes and inflation for long stretches, but there are flat or falling stretches too, and big differences between cities. Plan with global stocks at ~6–7% and a home that roughly keeps pace with inflation (see basics in plain language), never the best past decade, and treat good years as a bonus.
Going all in on today’s winners. Some people put most of their money into the largest or hottest stocks of the moment, because those just paid off. The leaders change. Of the 10 largest U.S. companies in 2000, only Microsoft was still in the top 10 by 2023. Buying the current top 10 means buying whatever just got expensive. The next decade’s leaders are usually not today’s, and you will not know which they are until after the run. A broad index fund owns today’s leaders, tomorrow’s, and the ones that drop out, without you guessing when to switch.
If your plan only works at 10–15% a year, the plan is broken, not the index fund. Fix it by saving more, working longer, or spending less (basics in plain language, “Too low”), not by gambling (see don’t speculate).
If the person pitching you sells something, the pitch is their business model. If the advice cannot name your situation (bills, province, pension, dates), it cannot know what your money needs to do. Check it against the five asks and the facts in this guide.
Avoid / Keep / Do — chasing heat:
- Avoid: buying anything you first heard about this month, going all in on the current top winners, switching funds on a headline, “catch-up” bets after lagging a friend.
- Keep: payday automation untouched, the boring core, and long-run results across whole market cycles (not last year’s) as your only evidence.
- Do (this week): add a 7-day wait for any unplanned investment buy over $500 (spending wants keep the 30-day list), and before ordering anything, answer “who is happily selling to me, and why?”
If you feel excitement, envy, or urgency, that is the signal to slow down, not speed up.